JUDAISM IN
CUBA 1959 – 1999 Moisés
Asís ICCAS Occasional Paper
Series December 2000
Introduction
Many years ago
I reached the conclusion that Judaism is a singular aradigm
of social consciousness and collective unconscious.
1-3
This definition has given me an
understanding of the survival of the Jewish people throughout human history.
Judaism has been unique in history as a
religion, a culture, and a civilization. Juridical
consciousness is given by the abundant mosaic of rabbinical and responsa legislation, constituting the basis for most constitutions
the world over, the juridical conscience of a great part of mankind, and the
regulation of Jewish practical life. Political
consciousness is expressed by the messianic ideal, the prophets,
Zionism with all its trends, and the kibbutzim movement. Moral consciousness is present in all the
biblical, deuterocanonical, rabbinical, responsa, and
later literature as a universal example of ethical thought and practice.
Judaism as a religion continues
to be unique, with variants in its practical interpretation going from the
orthodoxy of Chasidim and Mitnagdim to the conservative, reform,
reconstruction, and chavurot movements, just as Jewish theology is the
only theology based upon the interpretation and legal character of the Bible
and the Talmud, as well as on everyday life. The
science of Judaism includes a history in which everything has
already happened and nothing new can happen without repeating a previous Jewish
experience, due to the Jews’ long existence and many other expressions given by
the contributions of individuals such as Benedict de Spinoza, Albert Einstein,
Sigmund Freud, and others. Judaic art includes
the nusaf and liturgical poetry from ancient times,
biblical poetry, the music and intonation of synagogue readings, the Jewish rikudim, the
plastic arts, literature, and other expressions. The philosophy of Judaism encompasses the Bible, Moses Maimonides, Abraham Abulafia,
Spinoza, Martin Buber, and many others.
In every Jew there is something of that
unique paradigm of social consciousness, constantly interrelated with the
cumulative knowledge from history, juridical and political ideas, art, moral
philosophy, religion, and social psychology of the time and society the person
lives in. In every Jew there is a social consciousness and a collective
unconscious, even in those who hate themselves or who have other negative
identities.
When Fidel Castro’s Revolution came to
power in 1959, a huge majority of Cubans hoped that his political movement
would bring a better future to Cuba. Believing Fidel Castro’s promises of
democracy, social justice, and individual freedom, most Cubans — including most
of those who are now in exile in Miami and elsewhere — supported those dreams and
hopes at that time.
However, it was a paradox that Jews, who
historically have been involved in social reforms and revolutions because it is
a part of Judaism to look forward to a world of justice and peace, took a
different approach: 94 percent of the 15,000 Cuban Jews left the country in the
first years of the Revolution and went to the United States, Israel, Venezuela,
Panama, Costa Rica, and other countries. The history of the Jewish community of
Cuba during the past 40 years is the history of
the remaining 6 percent of a successful and proud community; it is the history
of those who stayed and their children.
2,3
In 1959, I was 6 years old, and my parents
were faithful believers in that Revolution. I hope that my personal account
will help you to understand the lives of those Jews who decided to stay in
Cuba and to continue to have a Jewish life, lamrot hakol (despite
everything).
A Community Born with the
Twentieth Century
The history of Jews in
Cuba begins in 1492, when Christopher Columbus
and his comrades arrived on the northeastern coast of the Cuban archipelago.
The same day that Columbus and his men left Europe was the deadline for Jews to leave Spain. It was the date of the enforcement of the
Catholic Kings’ Order to expel the Spanish Jews who did not accept conversion
(some hundreds of thousands, that is, most Jews), which was the reason for some
converted Jews, such as Rodrigo de Triana and Luis de
Torres, to embark on Columbus’ (himself a crypt-Jew) expedition and eventually
to arrive in Cuba. Later colonial history shows that from 1500 to the late
1800s, non-declared Jews participated directly in the sugarcane culture and
industry and in illegal trade with Dutch and British ships. There were even
Jewish corsairs and pirates arriving in Cuba.
The Jewish presence in
Cuba is also known through the Inquisition
courts, which processed some alleged crypt-Jews, although most of this
documentation disappeared after two large fires in Cartagena de Indias’ Inquisition headquarters. Perhaps the
most famous of those crypt-Jews was Morell de
Santa Cruz, Bishop of Havana during and after the
British occupation of Havana in the 1760s.
In 1850, Venezuelan General Narciso López, attempting to
annex
Cuba to the United States, landed in Cárdenas, a port city east of
Havana, and failed in this effort. His military
chief was a Hungarian Jew, Louis Schlesinger, and many other Jews took part in
the 95-percent foreign expedition, among them August Bondi,
who later returned to the United States and became known during the Civil War
on President Abraham Lincoln’s side.
It is important to underline the links and
sympathies of José Martí for the Jews. In 1874, a
former Hebrew language student in Madrid Central University’s faculty of
philosophy and literature, Martí was, until his death
in 1895, closely linked to Jews in New York, Key West, Tampa, Caracas, and
other cities. La Edad
de Oro magazine, written by Martí for children, was edited by Dacosta,
a Jew. Martí wrote dozens of articles about Jews,
among them, “Hanukkah” (December 24, 1881); “New York Letter” (January 6,
1882); “On Judah P. Benjamin” (1884); “NY Condemns Prosecution of Jews”
(February 1884); and “Carlyle, the Romans and the Sheep” (February 1884).
In 1882, Martí
publicly spoke at the Key West Israelite Colony, invited by brothers José, Max,
and Eduardo Steinberg; the board of directors donated to Martí
the funds from their social fund. Jews also constituted the “Isaac Abravanel” Club of the Partido Revolucionario Cubano.
Tampa,
Key West, and Caracas Jews contributed effective
help to Cuba’s fight for independence. Some of the
outstanding names are Lewis Fine, resident in Key West, who gave valuable help
to Martí; Horatio Rubens, member of the Junta Revolucionaria organized in New York, who was Partido Revolucionario Cubano’s attorney; Schwarz, General Calixto
García’s aid; General Carlos Roloff
(aka Akiva Roland) of the
War Treasury and director of the Veterans Archive, first Treasury of the
Republic; and the Steinberg brothers, who fought in the war.
On the Jews, Martí wrote, “De su
religión, los hebreos hacen patria. . .
. [From their religion, the Jews make their
homeland. . . .]
Somos un tanto hebreos, un poco a fortuna, y
esperamos siempre un mesías que nunca llega. Y no hay
más que un modo de ver llegar al mesías, y es
esculpirlo con nuestras propias manos.”
In a letter, Ejército Libertador Cubano Colonel
Fernando Figueredo wrote,
“Los cubanos deben vivir reconocidos a los hebreos, por su simpatía y por la
ayuda prestada a nuestra causa; por eso debemos bendecir
sus nombres.”
[Cubans must live acknowledging Jews, for their sympathy
and for their aid to our cause; for that we must bless their names.]
During the Spanish-American-Cuban War
(1898), some 3,500 Jewish soldiers and officers from the
United States volunteered to take part in the war,
according to the preliminary list of Jewish soldiers and sailors participating
in that war and published shortly after it.
4
In 1906, U.S. Jews founded the first
synagogue in
Cuba, the United Hebrew Congregation (Reform),
which was closed in the 1980s, and established the first Jewish cemetery in Guanabacoa, east Havana. In 1906, the Jewish population of Cuba was 1,000 people, and the entire Cuban
population was 1.5 million people.
In 1914, the Chevet
Ahim Sephardic Society was founded, at
Inquisidor Street between Luz and Santa Clara Streets, in
Old Havana, thanks to the affluence of thousands of Jewish immigrants from Turkey and the Balkan countries. They also
founded a sephardic cemetery not far from the United
Hebrew Congregation’s cemetery. In this society, my grandfather Moisés (I was named after him) was president of the Bikkur Holim society, a
beneficent organization for helping the sick and needy, and his cousin Mario Asís was president of the cemetery until he passed away in
1970. Chevet Ahim survived
the Revolution.
By 1925, there were 8,000 Jews in
Cuba (some 2,700 sephardic,
5,200 ashkenazic, and 100 Americans). Four ashkenazic Jews were in the small group that founded the
first Communist Party of Cuba in 1925: Grimberg,Vasserman,
Simjovich aka Grobart, and Gurbich. They
opposed the religious and community life of the other Jews.
Later, other Jewish institutions were
founded: the Centro Israelita de Cuba; Unión Sionista de Cuba (closed in
June 1978 by the communist regime, and its offices were handed over to the
Palestine Liberation Organization representation in
Havana); the Asociación
Femenina Hebrea de Cuba;
and the Comité Protector de Tuberculosos
y Enfermos Mentales. In
1935, an ORT vocational school was founded.
In 1935, the Jewish population of
Cuba had grown to 20,000 and peaked during the
World War II years. In 1941, the Comité Hebreo Antinazi and the Sociedad Israelita de Oriente (this later closed in the 1970s and reopened in the
late 1990s) were created. The Centro Popular Hebreo
carried out intense activity against Nazism.
B’nai B’rith Lodge (Maimonides 1516) was founded in 1943, and later the Adath Israel Religious Society, at the corner of Acosta and
Picota Streets, Old Havana; both have survived to
this day.
In 1952, there were 12,000 Jews in
Cuba (of these, 7,200 were ashkenazic),
as most of the war refugees had found their way to the United States. The 1950s coincide with the climax of the
economic growth of Jews who had arrived in Cuba 10 to 30 years earlier. In 1955, the Patronato de la Casa de la Comunidad
Hebrea de Cuba (mainly ashkenazic)
was founded at I and 13th Streets, Vedado,
Havana, and around that time the Centro Hebreo Sefaradí de Cuba was built
at 17th and E Streets, Vedado,
Havana. The government has allowed these two
centers to function continuously.
Why Leave, Why Stay?
The Jewish community of
Cuba began in 1898, when some of the 3,500
American-Jewish soldiers taking part in the Spanish-Cuban-American War decided
to live in Cuba and established the first Jewish cemetery
and temple there.
4
After that, during the first 50 years of
the twentieth century, thousands of Jews from
Turkey, Poland, Russia, Latvia, and elsewhere came to Cuba, mainly with the hope of going on to the United States, but the result was that many stayed in Cuba and felt very happy to share their fate
with the Cubans.
By 1959, the Jews in
Cuba had almost reached the climax of their
economic and social development.
The answer to why 94 percent of the Jews in
Cuba left the country during the first years of
the Revolution can be summarized in the words of Max Nordau:
“We are so old that in our history everything has happened and nothing new can
occur.” This explains why nearly all of the Jews did not believe in the
beautiful speeches on democracy and social justice delivered by Castro and
other Revolution leaders. Jews were professionals and businesspeople who had
recently learned the lessons of totalitarian regimes in Europe. There is a Jewish saying: “When things
don’t get better, don’t worry; they may get worse.”
In Cuba, the remaining 6 percent of the total
Jewish population were the more assimilated and those who had a belief in the
Revolution. Also, manyolder people who had no
strength to begin a new life abroad preferred to stay.
From my childhood, I have memories of
Passover celebrations at my grandparents’ home, the taste of matzoh,
curiosity about the Hebrew language, the non-consumption of pork or lard in our
home, and the Brith Milah or
circumcision ceremonies.
In 1970, one incident changed my life. I
tried to leave the country illegally with seven other people in two tiny boats
from the CaibariJn coast.
The boats sank, and we returned home but
were incarcerated by the political police, the Department of State Security. An
illegal exit was a political offense called a “Crime Against National Security
and Stability,” judged by a military court. I was judged and sentenced, even
though I was a minor. The political police officer lied. The attorney assigned
by the judge did not defend us. The trial was an offense to fair justice.
As a political prisoner at the age of 17, I
was doing forced labor for one year in Lenin Park, South Havana, along with some volunteer workers.
One of the volunteers, a very proud
communist, was discussing Granma’s
news about
Israel. “The worst thing Hitler did was not to
eliminate all the Jews.” I said nothing. After I had survived my minimum term
of one year out of a sentence of four years, as soon as I was free I decided
that I wanted to live a Jewish life with my community.
Indeed, I had a role in the preservation of
the community by actively participating in its institutions, by improving its
relations with other communities abroad and other religions at home, by writing
and lecturing on Judaism everywhere, by improving contacts with Israel for a
further massive aliyah (migration to Holy Land) of Cuban Jews,
and by creating a school that served to plant the seeds of Jewish identity in
the next generation. All of this was accomplished at a high cost. I survived
the difficult times with the help of many Jews, in spite of the political
hostility of some local Jewish leaders.
Finally, in 1993, I decided to leave
Cuba with my family.
The Community
The Jews of Cuba survived, despite their
isolation for 40 years and their dramatic depletion; the dearth of rabbis,
cantors (chazannim)
and professional teachers; the poverty of the community and its institutions;
their assimilation into the Cuban culture; and the restrictions (until 1991) on
religious practice in Cuba.
The only source for a demographic study of
Jews in
Cuba has been the Passover census: the registry
of people buying matzoth and other Passover products once a year. These
products have been donated since 1959 by the Jewish Canadian community and
since 1985 also by communities in Mexico, Panama, and other countries.
In 1989, according to my research,
5-7
the community was integrated by 892
people or 305 families. Of these people, 635 were Jews born from a Jewish mother
(70 percent) or from a Jewish father (30 percent).
Of a total of 194 couples, only in 14 were
both partners Jewish, which shows a 93 percent exogamy. In respect to
education, 22 percent of adult Jews had a university degree.
Although the above data are for 1989 (the
last year I was permitted to access the census), the study shows the situation
in the years prior to the “legalization” of religions in 1991. For the next 10
years, a process of intensive migration of hundreds of Cuban Jews to
Israel, the United States, and other countries took place. Many
non-Jewish partners and children in exogamic couples were converted to Judaism
by rabbis sent to Cuba by the American Jewish Joint Distribution
Committee. Many “non-Jewish Jews” (Isaac Deutscher’s
term for Jewish-born communists and other self-haters), 99 percent of them
married to non-Jews, felt frustrated by the communist ideology and famine and
approached the Jewish community after the Communist Party of Cuba stated in
late 1991 that its members were permitted to visit religious institutions and
even to profess religious beliefs. During the late 1990s, most of the activists
and leaders in Jewish institutions were Jews who had abhorred Judaism and Israel a few years earlier. Considering that
newcomers and the newborn are replacing Jews who die and those who leave the
country every year, a number of 1,000 appears to be close to or surpassing the
current actual demography. However, it is a fact that the only thing these
newcomers require — from a religious point of view — is to have their spouses
and children (and even themselves in many cases) converted to Judaism, as also
occurred in Russia and the former Soviet Republics after the disintegration of
the Soviet Union. This is also happening among the immigrants from the former Soviet Union to Israel.
Forty years of shrinkage, isolation,
atheism, anti-Israel propaganda, and Marxist indoctrination have done
considerable damage to the Cuban Jewish Community, demonstrated by the increase
in a lack of Jewish identityand almost 100 percent
exogamy.
After 1959, five synagogues in
Havana and one in Santiago de Cuba continued to be places of worship for
Jews, as well as a school and other institutions. In the 1970s, one of the
synagogues (Santiago de Cuba’s), the school, and the Zionist Union of
Cuba were closed to Jews (the synagogue was reopened in 1996), and another
synagogue, the United Hebrew Congregation, was empty and abandoned in the
1980s. Jewish life continued, however, and religious services were never
interrupted. The eldest members of the community, people in their seventies and
eighties, were the community’s true heroes and led the religious life for all
the years of the Cuban Revolution, despite many difficulties and negative
challenges, although there was always the fear of religious extinction because
of the high rate of assimilation and the lack of religious education at home
for the younger generations.
I realized the fact that children of
communists and “non-Jewish Jews” were showing interest in their roots. Two
things came to my mind:
1) Hanson’s law in sociology, “The third
generation remembers that the second tries to forget,” and
2) the story of Rabbi Yohannan
ben Zakkai, who, in the
year 70 CE, when the Jews and the Second Temple were being destroyed by the Romans,
understood that only education could preserve Judaism for future generations,
so he created his famous school in Yavneh, which
ensured the survival of Judaism to this day.
The Cuban version of Yavneh
was the opening of “Tikkun Olam”
Hebrew Sunday School in
Havana in the early 1980s. In Hebrew, tikkun olam means
“healing, amendment, repair, transformation of the world,” and it is our wish
expressed in prayers and especially at Yom Kippur, to repair or mend the world
to make it just and peaceful. At the beginning, I was the school’s principal
and only teacher for a group of 12 children and a few adults. As time passed,
the school grew, and we added more teachers for dozens of students at different
levels of learning. The purpose of the school was to teach Jewish identity and
values and to plant a seed of love for Judaism and its history through the
study of the Hebrew language, liturgy, songs, dance, history, Israel, and comparative religion. I am very proud
that some of those students who started out not knowing the meaning of being a
Jew have continued their studies in rabbinical seminaries in Argentina and the
United States, and others have immigrated (made aliyah) to Israel or continued to
teach other Jews in Cuba. The lessons were accompanied by discussions,
lectures, and films.
While we observed our religious life and
traditions, we also kept alive social organizations like B’nai
B’rith, Bikur Holim, and young men’s and women’s groups. Beginning in the
1980s, thanks to personal contacts, we cooperated with the Ecumenical Council
of Cuba, the Catholic Church, and Protestant churches.
Politics and Religion
Cubans never were anti-Semitic people, and
Jews in
Cuba received the same treatment as other
immigrants. A nation that persecutes Jews cannot last long.
The Revolution was very respectful to Jews
as a community, although its negative attitude toward religion, Zionism, and
Israel affected the Jewish community very much.
As religious people, we experienced exactly
the same degree of discrimination and problems with access to jobs and
universities as Christians and all other religious people in
Cuba. As Jews, we noticed that there was always
a cloud of suspicion over us because of our support of Israel and Jews in other countries. While we
experienced discrimination, there was no anti-Semitism.
In fact, Castro’s Revolution had an
ambiguous relationship with the Jews. On the positive side, it permitted
freedom of expression, even the import of food donations for Passover and New
Years and the domestic purchase of other products, as well as the distribution
of kosher meat to the Jews instead of other meat and poultry through the ration
cards. The Cuban criminal code protects citizens from the manifestations of
national, religious, and racial hate.
On the negative side, for years
Cuba trained thousands of Palestinian
terrorists, even those of Abu Nidal and George Habash. The government published a lot of anti-Zionist,
anti-Israel propaganda, showing Jewish literature and art and even the
Holocaust as Zionist propaganda. Cubans could never read books by Anne Frank,
Isaac Bashevis Singer, Eli Wiesel,
Shmuel Yosef Agnon, or Bernard Malamud, for
example. Cuba has been Israel’s worst enemy at the United Nations and
took the initiative to advocate embargoes, sanctions, and isolation against Israel, even the infamous resolution “Zionism =
Racism,” which was so unfair and noxious for Israel and the Jewish people worldwide. I
attended the session of the General Assembly of the United Nations in late
December 1991, when the infamous resolution “Zionism = Racism” was
overwhelmingly canceled, and I will always remember the nonsensical arguments
by the Cuban delegate justifying his anti-Zionist vote.
Finally, Cuban Jews have shared the same
fate as Cuban Christians in being discriminated against in jobs and
universities. Some were sent to the Unidades Militares de Ayuda a la Producción — forced labor camps for young political
dissenters, religious people, gays, and exit applicants — in the late 1960s.
All Jewish activists were under close surveillance all the time. And those
“non-Jewish Jews” who reached positions of responsibility in the armed forces,
Communist Party, and bureaucratic structures of power and professional
relevance had to work twice as hard and show much more institutional loyalty
than others in order to reach and keep their status.
Although the Jewish community was permitted
certain privileges, such as keeping the management of its kosher butchery shop
and receiving supplies of ritual products, the Cuban government maintained some
degree of harassment against those Jews who were not sympathetic with the
communist system, especially if they had any leadership position in the Jewish
community. Thus, they provoked and forced Moisés Baldas, an old Zionist (1906,
Lvov, Poland – 1994, Tel Aviv) who assumed the
leadership of the Jewish community when most Jews left, to resign. He was
replaced by an unscrupulous anti-Zionist, anti-religious Jew, José Miller, who
had made most of his career as a dentist and a high-ranking officer in Castro’s
army and had shown considerable admiration for Castro himself and communism. In
1978, Miller took control of the community, and since then he has ruled it
according to the government’s interests. Widely regarded as a very corrupt,
nepotistic, and authoritarian person, he has served as the internal police of
the Jewish community and the external lobbyist for Castro in exchange for
impunity for his actions. In addition to his personal appropriation of cash and
resources donated by foreign Jewish communities, Miller facilitated the aliyah (immigration) to Israel mainly for those who would constitute a
burden on the state of Israel. In 1978, he kept secret from the Cuban Jewish
community Castro’s promise to Miami negotiator Bernardo Benes
that the Cuban leader would grant exit permits to all Cuban Jews wishing to
leave the country. The Jewish community never knew about this.
Although anti-Semitism was never practiced
by the Cuban government, most of the population, or the Catholic Church, during
the first three decades of the Cuban Revolution, some anti-Zionist books with
strong anti-Semitic elements were published and distributed by the Cuban
government, the sole owner of all publishing houses in the country. Some
examples were Sionismo: El fascismo de la estrella de David (Zionism: The Fascism of the
Star of David) by Prensa Latina journalist José
Antonio (Tony) Fernández Pérez
(La Habana: Editora Política, 1979), which is an offense to the Jewish people’s
history and religion. The Grupo de Estudios e Información sobre el Sionismo (GEIS), Group
for Zionism Studies and Information, published in 1983 the papers of a
symposium held in Havana on the “Zionist penetration in Latin America,” whose
actual concern was the Jewish presence in this continent. One of the authors,
paradoxically, was an assimilated Cuban half-Jew, Rafael Pinto, whose
grandfather acted his whole life as a rabbi for the sephardic
community in
Havana.
Nabil Khalil Khalil,
Prensa Latina Palestinian journalist, in his book
Propagandistas del terror (La Habana: Ciencias
Sociales, 1987) calls films such as “L’Affaire Dreyfuss” (France,
1898, “the first Zionist film”); “Samson and Delilah” (1908); “Moses” (1910); “The
Great Dictator” (1940); “The Diary of Anne Frank” (1960); “Funny Girl” (1968);
and others “Zionist propaganda,” as well as works by writers Agnon and Malamud. Khalil denies the reality of the Holocaust and repeats
falsehoods from other sources with no interference from the strict Cuban
censors. Mahmud Abbas (Abbu Mazzen)’s book, La otra cara:
la verdad delas relaciones secretas entre el nazismo y el sionismo (La Habana:
PLO Embassy, 1987), states, among other things, that the Nazis killed some
hundreds of thousands of Jews (six million cipher is “an invention by
Zionists”) but that the Nazis did not intend to do it — they were forced to do
it by the Zionists, as this was convenient for them. The author also justifies
the existence of Nazi crematoria.
These books plus others and many articles
in newspapers and magazines had no impact on the Cuban population and even went
unnoticed by most of the Jewish community. In publishing these books, the
publishers were seduced by the political content of the titles and apparently
were unaware of their fallacies and anti-Semitism. This also explains the
frequent mistakes in names, dates, quotations, and other information appearing
in all of the above-mentioned publications.
Legal Protection and
Relations with the State
Some articles will be mentioned from the Código Penal (1988), the Cuban criminal code,
that grant protection to the Cuban population, including the Jews, against
discrimination, attacks, and limitations to the development of religious,
cultural, or community life. Some ministerial legislation forbidding religious
people from working in certain activities or studying in universities was
deleted in the 1990s after the change of policy by the Communist Party of Cuba.
However, from a historical point of view, I must state that for many years the
access of religious people to the Academy of Sciences (today’s Ministry of
Science, Technology and Environment); the Ministries of Foreign Affairs,
Interior, Armed Forces, Foreign Trade, and Foreign Collaboration; the political
and “non-governmental” organizations (are there any in Cuba?); and other bodies
was explicitly forbidden, as well as their access to “ideological” professions
in universities, such as psychology, education, law, sociology, diplomacy,
journalism, medicine, and others.
The following are some of the articles in
the 1988 Criminal Code that
protect the practice of Judaism and all religions in
Cuba:
Art. 116. Genocide.
Art. 120. Crime of apartheid.
Art. 291. Crime against the free expression
of thought.
Art. 292. Crime against the rights of
meeting, manifestation, association, complaint, and petition.
Art. 294. Crime against the freedom of
cults.
Art. 295. Crime against the right of
equality.
Although the Cuban Constitution and the
codes have many articles that are not respected in practice, at least in theory
a group of laws protects any group against abuses, but the general rule that
covers all Cuban legislation appears to be “what is good for the state and
communism is good and will be protected.”
Any complaint by the Jewish community, or
from any religious body, is presented to the Office for Religious Affairs, a
department of the Communist Party Central Committee that has had a strong
authority since 1985 to grant protection and to serve petitions to all
religions acting within politically established limits.
Actually, in the 1990s there was a marked
improvement between the Jewish community (as well as all other religions) and
the Cuban government. This improvement came about through mutual concessions.
Life in the 1990s
In 1991, the Communist Party of Cuba
changed its policy of opposition to religion and opened its doors to believers
of all religions. In practical terms, this meant that thousands of communists
began to attend churches and synagogues. And maybe a few religious communists
were accepted as members of the Party. This change of policy and the disastrous
economic situation in Cuba after the disappearance of the Soviet Union as the main supplier of economic aid to Cuba brought many “non-Jewish Jews” to the
community. The fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 was for Cuba the failure of ideology and the beginning
of hard times of hunger and despair. Cuba’s rates of malnutrition, suicide, poverty,
unemployment, diseases, prostitution, and uncertainty are worse now than they
have ever been for the past 50 years.
All those who are entering
Cuba’s Jewish community are welcome, no matter
who they are or how much they have cursed or ignored their Jewish roots. In
Hebrew, teshuvah means “return,” and it is the word for
repentance.
It is never too late for teshuvah, to
come back to the right way.
Beginning in 1992, the American Jewish
Joint Distribution Committee started to give special attention to Cuban Jews:
rabbis and specialists are regularly sent to help the community to organize;
improve the education; perform conversions, circumcisions, and weddings; and
supply the spiritual and physical needs of the community. Other organizations
and communities have increased their support by donating school supplies,
medicines, religious books and articles, food, clothing, and so on. A large
amount of money has been donated to build a synagogue in Camagüey
city and to repair the synagogues in Havana. In 1996, the synagogue of
Santiago de Cuba was returned to the community and
reopened, a women’s organization was created, and a Hadassah chapter was
started, with the participation of Cuban Jewish doctors who distribute
medicines to people who are ill.
The increased respect and tolerance shown
by the Cuban authorities toward Cuban Jews, as well as toward people of all
religions in Cuba (including the long-time prosecuted and incarcerated
Jehovah’s Witnesses and fundamentalist Christians), has encouraged an increased
response from abroad in the amount of food, medicines, and other supplies
donated to Cuban institutions. Foreigners have also increased lobbying efforts
against the United States’ trade embargo of Cuba.
Many Cuban Jews have expressed their desire
to live in Israel since 1992, and more than 200 people have made aliyah to Israel in small groups of families. In
the 1990s, other Cuban Jews emigrated to Europe, the United States, and Latin
America. Nonetheless, Jewish life continues in Cuba — the community replaces
itself with newcomers, young people emigrate, and older people pass away.
The Future of Judaism in
Cuba
The Talmud Yerushalmi
(Berakoth 9.1) says, “As long as a man breathes he
should not lose hope.”
The worst times for Cuban Jews are over. The
community has survived periods of isolation, religious restrictions, and the
sudden loss of 94 percent of its population. Assimilation and an anti-Israel
policy have had their effects.
Cuba will always have a Jewish community.
When Cubans reach their democratic goals, many Jews from other countries will
want to take advantage of business opportunities in Cuba, and others will
decide to live there. The present Jewish community in Cuba will lose some
members by reunification with their families who live in the United States and
Israel, while most Cuban Jews will not return to Cuba from these countries
unless for retirement.
However, many Jews in Argentina, Mexico,
Venezuela, Canada, Europe, and the United States will find it very attractive
to invest or practice their
professions in Cuba.
These outsiders will form the next
community in Cuba and will find synagogues where Jews of different generations
worshipped every day and where every shabbat for 40 years was celebrated under the most difficult
conditions.
“Jewish history is a history of martyrdom
and learning,” as historian Heinrich Graetz said, but
it is also a history of faith and hope.
References
Numbered citations in the text correspond
to the numbers of the following references.
1. Asís, Moisés. 1980.
Judaísmo social y derechos humanos.
La Habana (Unpublished manuscript).
2. AsRs,
MoisJs.1987. “Los judíos de Cuba: buscando
alternativas en la educación judía.”
Buenos Aires: Centro de Estudios
Judaicos (CEJ). Cuban Jews: The Challenges of Jewish Education in a Changing
Society. Presented at the 11th Conference on Alternatives in Jewish
Education (CAJE), University of Maryland, College Park, August 3-7, 1986.
3. Fingueret,
Manuela. 1988. “¿Es difícil ser judío en Cuba?” Nueva Sión (Buenos Aires) 39 (674): 18, January 23.
4. Adler, C. 1900. “Jews in the
Spanish-American War.” The American Jewish
Year Book 5661 (1900-1901) Vol. 2, 526-622.
Philadelphia:
The Jewish Publication Society of America.
5. Asís, Moisés. 1989.
“El judaísmo cubano durante 30 años de revolución (1959-1989).” Coloquio (Buenos Aires) 22: 39-54, December.
6. Asís, Moisés. 1990.
“Situación actual y perspectivas para el judaísmo en Cuba.” Ensayos sobre Judaísmo Latinoamericano. Buenos
Aires: Milá. Presented at the 5th International Congress on Latin
American Judaism Studies, Buenos Aires, LAJSA, August 14-19, 1989.
7. Asís, Moisés. 1990.
“Yahadut Kubah bemeshekh shloshim shanot mahpachah (1959-1989).”
Yahadut Zemanenu (Jerusalem)
6: 325-339.
Dr. Moisés Asís, D.J., has a B.Sc. in Information/Library Science from
the University of Havana; a Ph.D. Honoris Causa in Experimental Hypnosis, and an M.D. in
Alternative Medicine from the Open International University for Complementary
Medicines. He was a student at the Latin American Rabbinical Seminary in Buenos
Aires, thanks to a Joint Distribution Committee Fellowship, and is the author
of 15 books and over 100 articles on scientific and social subjects, including
Judaism. For 25 years, he was an activist in the Jewish community of Cuba; the
vice-president of B’nai B’rith
Maimonides; and the founder, principal, and teacher
of the “Tikkun Olam” Hebrew
Sunday School in Havana. In Cuba, he was a researcher and therapist. In late
1993, he immigrated to the United States. At present, he works as a protective
investigator at the Florida Department of Children and Families, Miami, and is
a member of Temple Judea in Coral Gables.
An earlier version of this paper was
presented at the Third Annual South Florida Symposium on Cuba, “Faith and
Power:
Religion in Contemporary Cuba,” September
12-13, 1998, University of Miami James L. Knight Center.
|